Discography
Note: I will say right off that all of the For Against albums are excellent!
However, I figured newcomers would like some idea of how the albums to relate to each other, and for that reason, I have added a short, subjective description of each release.
If you'd like to contribute your own comments or reviews, please contact me and I'll add them!
I've also added The Millions' releases to this page.
For Against
Autocrat
Independent Project Records
1985
Both of these songs are on Echelons, and are two of the more memorable songs from the album.
As far I know, this was the band's first release and is no longer available.
Echelons
reviews
- Shine
- Daylight
- Get On With It
- Echelons
- It's a Lie
- Autocrat
- Forget Who You Are
- Loud and Clear
- Broke My Back
IPR
IPC19
1987
vinyl, tape
Words On Music
WM14
2004
CD
Less polished than their later albums, this still has some killer moments and catchy tunes.
Its album cover was nominated for a Grammy in 1987, and Jack Rabid gave it his #4 pick in
The Big Takeover #23.
Good news; after being out of print for several years,
Echelons has been re-released, this time on CD, by
Words On Music.
In the Marshes
reviews
- Tibet
- Amnesia
- The Purgatory Salesman
- Amen Yves
- Fate
- In the Marshes
- Amnesia (Studio Version) [cd only]
- Amen Yves (Original Version) [cd only]
IPR
IPR000029
1990
vinyl
Words On Music
WM22
2007
CD
Allegedly recorded in 1986 [I've also read that it was recorded between
Echelons and
December],
this was released by IPR on vinyl in 1990 in a limited edition of 2500.
It consists of six keyboard and drum-machine laden demos of "4AD-like" dreaminess.
With songs that neither overwhelm nor irritate,
In the Marshes is listenable and occasionally memorable,
though atypical of the band's material.
Jack Rabid gave it his #38 pick in
The Big Takeover #29.
NOTE: The 2007 CD reissue adds 2 bous tracks.
December
reviews
- Sabres
- Stranded in Greenland
- Svengali
- They Said
- The Effect
- December
- The Last Laugh
- Paperwhites
- Clandestine High Holy
IPR
D2-74781
1988
CD, ???
Words On Music
WM16
2005
CD
This is a fantastic album, full of deliciously icy vocals, blizzards of swirling, shimmering guitars, and crystalline rhythms,
all coming together to form a perfect snapshot of the beauty of winter.
Jack Rabid gave it his #1 pick in
The Big Takeover #25.
His advice: "
If you only buy one LP this year on my recommendation, make it this one. It's too great for me to say how incredible it is, I hope you see for yourself."
You Only Live Twice
- You Only Live Twice
- Today Today
IPR
1993
Both of these songs are on
Aperture.
This was the first release with the new line up.
By the way, "You Only Live Twice" has nothing to do with the James Bond song!
Jack Rabid gave this single his #9 pick in
The Big Takeover #31.
Don't Do Me Any Favors
IPR
1993
All three of these songs are on
Aperture.
They are all really good!
IPR calls this an EP (instead of a single), so maybe these are extended versions of the songs, but I wouldn't bet on it!
Aperture
reviews
- Don't Do Me Any Favors
- Breathless
- Nightmare Life
- Spent
- Mindframed
- I Wish
- Unspeakable
- Over Nepal
- You Only Live Twice
- Today Today
- Memorial
IPR
IPCD45
1993
CD
Not so much an album as a collection of singles and b-sides; many of the songs have abrupt intros
(almost as if the engineer tried to reduce the length of the album by fast-forwarding to the vocals)
and a rushed relentlessness that, though sometimes fatiguing, often works perfectly, yielding some of the band's greatest songs.
Aperture earned Jack's #4 pick in
The Big Takeover #34.
Mason's California Lunchroom
reviews
- seesick
- vacuum
- crossed
- tagalong
- hindsight
- coursing
- vista
- infamous
- reinventing the wheel
- mirage
- blow
Rainbow Quartz
RQTZ003
1995
CD
Despite the down-to-earth title and terse song names, this album tends to wander and linger in delicious otherworldly excursions
ranging from the post-punk "Tagalong" and "Vista" to the tenderly contemplative "Blow".
Though it sometimes lacks the incessant focus and energy of the band's earlier offerings (imagine sparkling slopes of sugar),
it enrichens the band's sound via experimentation and a greater underlying maturity (thick, woodsy maple syrup).
Jack gave it his #2 pick in
The Big Takeover #37.
Shelf Life
reviews
- Shadow
- Wintersong
- Starblind
- Lost
- Profile
- Lilacs
- Harbor
- Forever
- Times Square GoGo Boy
- Seascape
World Domination
WDM10072-2
1997
CD
It's a lot mellower than the previous albums (and I'm not a big mellow music fan), and the last two songs are covers,
but there's something irresistable about the ultra-smooth vocals and guitars; I can't stop playing this album!!!
For an in depth review, check out
Randy's Review.
Jack gave it his #3 pick in
The Big Takeover #40.
Coalesced
reviews
- medication
- so long
- fuel
- coalesced
- outside a heart
- shelflife
- love you
Words On Music
WM11
2002
CD
Only seven songs, but they're great!
This is yet another excellent album.
Jack Rabid gave it his #1 pick for 2002 in
The Big Takeover.
You can buy it from the
Words On Music site, which also has some mp3s.
Shade Side Sunny Side
reviews
- glamour
- underestimate
- why are you so angry?
- aftertaste
- friendly fires
- game over
- spirit lake
- quite please
- irresistable
Words On Music
WM25
2008
CD
Wow!
These songs are longer, darker, and more aggressive than anything they've done since
December (
1988).
This is a superb return to the old post-punk feel.
I love it!
You can buy it from
Words On Music which also has some mp3s.
Never Been
- Sameness
- Different Departures
- Black Willows
- Antitode
- Of a Time
- Per Se
- Specificity
- The Tenebrists
- You Fade
Black Soap
- Black Soap
- Dark Good Friday
- Amen Yves (White Circles)
Words On Music
WM29
2011
CD
This first release in an "archive" series contains three very early studio recordings (from 1984), unavailable on any albums.
You can buy it from
Amazon or
Words On Music, which also has some mp3 excerpts.
Live:
I don't know of any live material.
Video:
There are at least two videos, "Autocrat" and "Echelons." (information courtesy Randy)
The Millions
M is for Millions
- guilty
- smiling and shaking
- riga (freedom)
- agnus dei
- west
- sometimes
- breathe
- in the alley
- scream
- voices
- ordinary men
Smash
314 510 108-2
1991
CD, tape
This is a very nice debut!
Lori Allison's voice takes a while to get used to (well, so did Jeffrey Running's), but the album shares much of the early For Against sound.
Many of these songs stick in your head, most notabye "Riga" and "In the Alley."
Highly recommended for any For Against fan.
Raquel
lyrics
- play sacrifice
- led by beauty
- drain the pool and drown
- manic and slipping
- indians and drums
- answer with fever
- hundred ways
- raquel
Thermometer Sound Surface
7007-41954-2-8
1994
CD
This is more polished sounding than the debut, though a little less exciting and memorable in the long run.
The promotional version (mentioned below) looks more promising.
Special RAQUEL Promo
lyrics
- indians and drums 7:38
- play sacrifice 5:01
- led by beauty 4:32
- hundred ways 4:57
- hands and knees 7:17
- drain the pool and drown 5:36
- ruth starkman 5:54
- manic and slipping 5:52
- raquel 5:20
- answer with fever 5:41
- vicious 5:46
- indians & drums (radio edit) 5:04
Dream Circle Records (Germany)
DCD 94611
1994
CD
Bill Hunter writes:
The sticker on the cd says: 'This promo is the European version of The Millions' - Raquel.
The Domestic version will include remixes of the featured Euorpean singles "Manic & Slipping", "Play Sacrifice", and "Led By Beauty".'
Outside covers are the same, except the font used for the word raquel is different.
Inside cover dedication excludes dorothy kushner, band photos have the band sitting on a fence in the dark and Lori kneeling in front.